Namami Gange Programme
Claim
Lacks context
Delivery
Partly delivered
The commitment set a specific and checkable standard — sewerage for 100 per cent of the waste water from Ganga towns, completed and functioning, with Clean Ganga achieved by 2022. The CAG's performance audit of Namami Gange, which covers the years immediately before this promise, shows why that standard was ambitious: sewage treatment contracts for the whole programme were to be awarded by September 2016, and as of August 2017 project reports for 1,397 MLD of capacity had still not been approved. Only eight to 63 per cent of programme funds were used, ₹2,133.76 crore lay unspent, and the river basin management plan the whole exercise depends on did not exist.
“Namami Gange: A matter of Pride. We are committed to ensure a clean and uninterrupted flow of river Ganga from Gangotri to Ganga Sagar. We will ensure that the sewerage infrastructure to deal with 100% of the waste water from the Ganga towns is completed and is functioning effectively, and take steps to enhance the river flow… Achieve the goal of Clean Ganga by 2022.”This audit predates the claim
This audit's period ended on 31 Mar 2017, before the claim was made on 8 Apr 2019. It does not assess this claim, and is shown for context only.
Audit period: 1 Apr 2014 — 31 Mar 2017
For 2014-15 to 2016-17, only eight to 63 per cent of programme funds were used against revised estimates, with ₹2,133.76 crore unspent at the National Mission for Clean Ganga and the entire ₹198.14 crore Clean Ganga Fund unused for want of an action plan. Long-term action plans were not finalised more than six and a half years after the agreement with the IIT consortium, leaving no river basin management plan eight years after the river basin authority was notified. All sewage treatment plant works were to be awarded by September 2016; reports for 1,397 MLD were still unapproved in August 2017, and 26 of 46 sanctioned sewage, interception and canal projects costing ₹2,710.14 crore were delayed. Staffing ran 44 to 65 per cent short at the mission.
Audit period
The audit period closes before the claim was made. The orange span is the gap the audit does not cover.
₹2,133.76 crore of programme funds unspent at the National Mission for Clean Ganga
This audit covers 2014-15 to 2016-17 and therefore predates the promise; it is cited for the baseline the 2019 commitment was made from. Sewage capacity commissioned since 2017 has grown substantially and is not covered by any audit we hold.
Performance Audit of Rejuvenation of River Ganga (Namami Gange), Ministry of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation
The 2019 Sankalp Patra's Ganga commitment is unusually precise for a manifesto, and it names a date. It promises "a clean and uninterrupted flow of river Ganga from Gangotri to Ganga Sagar", undertakes that "the sewerage infrastructure to deal with 100% of the waste water from the Ganga towns is completed and is functioning effectively", and lists among its targets: "Achieve the goal of Clean Ganga by 2022."
Two of those words do the work. Not built — "completed and functioning effectively". Not most — "100%".
The only CAG performance audit of Namami Gange covers 2014-15 to 2016-17, which is before this promise rather than during it. That makes it useless as a verdict on delivery and valuable as a baseline: it records the state of the programme at the moment the 2019 commitment was made, and therefore what the promise was asking the programme to do in three years.
On sewage — the whole of the "100% of waste water" undertaking — the audit's finding is that the programme had not yet finished ordering the work. "As per the target dates, award for the work of all the Sewage Treatment Plants was to be completed by September 2016. National Mission for Clean Ganga is yet to finalise and approve Detailed Project Reports for projects totalling 1,397 MLD capacity as of August 2017." Of the 46 sewage, interception and canal projects that had been sanctioned, "there were delays in 26 projects costing ₹2,710.14 crore".
On money, the constraint was not the budget. "Only eight to 63 per cent of the funds were utilised during 2014-15 to 2016-17, as compared to Revised Estimate", with ₹2,133.76 crore sitting unspent at the mission. The Clean Ganga Fund — the vehicle for public and diaspora donations — held ₹198.14 crore and had spent none of it, "due to non-finalization of action plan."
On the plan, which is what "uninterrupted flow" depends on: long-term action plans contracted to a consortium of IITs were still not final more than six and a half years after signing, so the mission "does not have a river basin management plan even after a lapse of more than eight years of National Ganga River Basin Authority notification." And the mission was running 44 to 65 per cent short of staff, with no proposal made to strengthen the state programme groups.
Sewage treatment capacity on the Ganga has grown considerably since 2017, and no audit we hold covers that period, so this fact-check does not assert what happened to the 2022 target. What it can state is that the promise of complete, functioning sewerage for every Ganga town by 2022 was made from a starting point where the contracts had not been awarded, the plan had not been written, and most of the money had not been spent. Our verdict is lacks context.
BJP Sankalp Patra 2019 — Lok Sabha election manifesto
“Through this Sankalp Patra, you would get a glimpse of the challenges of the yesteryears, the indomitable efforts made by 130 crore Indians to overcome those challenges and our collective vision for the future… There are two commitments that I am extremely passionate about — doubling of farmer income and housing for all, by the year 2022.”
Performance Audit of Rejuvenation of River Ganga (Namami Gange), Ministry of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation
“Only eight to 63 per cent of the funds were utilised during 2014-15 to 2016-17, as compared to Revised Estimate. Funds amounting to ₹2,133.76 crore, ₹422.13 crore and ₹59.28 crore were lying unutilised with National Mission for Clean Ganga, various State Programme Management Groups and Executing Agencies/Central Public Sector Undertakings respectively as on 31 March 2017.”