Bharatiya Janata Party · 2019
Claim
Lacks context
Delivery
Partly delivered
A correction first: 'zero budget natural farming' is not the 2019 promise. The manifesto committed to chemical-free organic farming on an additional 20 lakh hectares of hilly, tribal and rainfed areas within five years, plus an e-commerce portal for organic produce. The national mission that now carries this work was approved only on 25 November 2024, after the term ended. On its progress the Ministry of Agriculture told Parliament on 11 August 2026 that 24,102 clusters have been formed covering 12.60 lakh hectares with 26.76 lakh farmers enrolled, 8,100 bio-input resource centres and 40,182 trained community resource persons. That is short of 20 lakh hectares and it arrived after the deadline, on a mission launched for a later term.
“To ensure greater promotion and increase profitability under organic farming, we will take the following steps: We will promote chemical-free organic farming in an additional 20 lakh hectare of hilly, tribal and rainfed areas in the next 5 years. We will launch a dedicated e-commerce portal to enhance the availability of organic produce to the doorsteps of consumers.”No CAG performance audit published
No CAG performance audit covering this scheme has been published. The absence of an audit is not evidence that the claim is either accurate or inaccurate.
No CAG audit of natural or organic farming programmes has been tabled in a report we hold. The evidence on yields cited by the ministry is from an ICAR network study, described qualitatively without published figures in this answer.
No audit period to plot — no CAG performance audit covering this scheme has been published.
24,102 clusters covering 12.60 lakh hectares with 26.76 lakh farmers enrolled under the National Mission on Natural Farming
The ministry states that district-wise and gender-wise data on natural farming is not maintained centrally, so who is adopting it and where cannot be checked from this source.
Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 331, Promotion of Natural Farming — answer by the Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare
This entry was imported as a promise on "zero budget natural farming". That phrase appears in the 2019 budget speech, not the manifesto. What the manifesto promised, under organic farming, is a number and a deadline: "We will promote chemical-free organic farming in an additional 20 lakh hectare of hilly, tribal and rainfed areas in the next 5 years", along with "a dedicated e-commerce portal to enhance the availability of organic produce to the doorsteps of consumers", goshalas linked to organic farming, and organic eco-tourism.
The national programme that now carries this agenda came after the term. "The Union Cabinet approved the National Mission on Natural Farming (NMNF) on 25th November 2024 to promote Natural Farming" — six months after the term the promise belonged to had ended.
Its progress so far, as the Ministry of Agriculture reported to the Lok Sabha on 11 August 2026: "Till date, 24,102 clusters have been formed covering 12.60 lakh Ha area, 26.76 lakh farmers enrolled, 8,100 Bio-Input Resource Centres (BRCs) established and 40,182 Krishi Sakhi/Community Resource Persons (CRPs) deployed under the Mission."
Twelve point six lakh hectares against a promise of an additional twenty lakh — and this is coverage under a mission that began after the five years were up. Chemical-free farming under the older Paramparagat Krishi Vikas Yojana and the north-east organic value chain mission continued through the term, but this answer does not report their area and we will not import figures we have not sourced.
Two things about the evidence base are worth stating.
The ministry cannot say who is farming this way or where: "District wise data as well as gender data is not maintained centrally." For a mission organised in clusters with community resource persons, that is a real gap in monitoring.
And the case for the practice rests on a study described without numbers. The Indian Council of Agricultural Research has run a network programme since 2020-21 across 20 centres in 16 states evaluating eight cropping systems, and the answer summarises it: "Study shows that if natural farming is adopted with the correct techniques and in a balanced manner, yields improve", with reduced chemical costs raising net profits. The conditional — "if… with the correct techniques and in a balanced manner" — is doing work, and no yield or income figures are published in the answer.
On the e-commerce portal for organic produce, the answer says nothing.
Our verdict is lacks context.
BJP Sankalp Patra 2019 — Lok Sabha election manifesto
“Through this Sankalp Patra, you would get a glimpse of the challenges of the yesteryears, the indomitable efforts made by 130 crore Indians to overcome those challenges and our collective vision for the future… There are two commitments that I am extremely passionate about — doubling of farmer income and housing for all, by the year 2022.”
Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 331, Promotion of Natural Farming — answer by the Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare
“The Union Cabinet approved the National Mission on Natural Farming (NMNF) on 25th November 2024 to promote Natural Farming. Till date, 24,102 clusters have been formed covering 12.60 lakh Ha area, 26.76 lakh farmers enrolled, 8,100 Bio-Input Resource Centres (BRCs) established and 40,182 Krishi Sakhi/Community Resource Persons (CRPs) deployed under the Mission… District wise data as well as gender data is not maintained centrally… Indian Council of Agricultural Research has initiated a study in 2020-21 through All India Network Programme on Natural Farming (previously AINP-Organic Farming) with 20 cooperating centres covering 16 States to evaluate 8 major cropping systems… Study shows that if natural farming is adopted with the correct techniques and in a balanced manner, yields improve… reducing chemical costs increases farmers' net profits.”